If you believe a loved one’s will is invalid, challenging it can create a difficult dilemma.
On one hand, you may have legitimate concerns about undue influence, lack of capacity, or another defect in the will. On the other hand, the will may contain a no-contest clause, sometimes called an in terrorem clause, that threatens to disinherit any beneficiary who brings a challenge. The purposes of such clauses are to discourage litigation and protect the testator’s chosen estate plan after death.
A typical no-contest clause may look like this:
If any beneficiary under this Will directly or indirectly contests this Will, or any of its provisions, any share or interest given to that beneficiary under this Will shall be revoked and shall pass as though that beneficiary had predeceased me.
Although no-contest clauses vary considerably in their wording, most operate in the same basic way: a beneficiary who challenges a will risks losing what that will otherwise provides.
Washington Law Recognizes No-Contest Clauses
In Washington State, no-contest clauses do not automatically bar beneficiaries from seeking relief. Whether a beneficiary risks forfeiting an inheritance depends on the language of the clause, the type of claim being asserted, and the circumstances surrounding the challenge. Just as importantly, the practical risk varies from beneficiary to beneficiary. A beneficiary who stands to receive a substantial inheritance may have a lot to lose if a no-contest clause is enforce, while a person who receives little or nothing under the will may have little or no inheritance at risk.
Washington courts generally recognize no-contest clauses as valid and enforceable. A typical clause provides that a beneficiary who challenges the validity of a will forfeits the gift the beneficiary otherwise would have received. These clauses may also appear in trusts.
The scope of a clause depends on its wording. A narrow clause may apply only when a beneficiary challenges the validity of the will. A broader clause may also address objections to provisions of the will, efforts to remove the personal representative, claims concerning estate administration, or proceedings that seek to increase the beneficiary’s share.
For example, in Estate of Kubick (1973), a clause applying to challenges to “any provisions of this Will” was broad enough to encompass an effort to remove the named executor for breach of fiduciary duty. A beneficiary therefore should not assume that a proceeding falls outside a no-contest clause simply because it is not labeled a “will contest.”
The “Good Faith and Probable Cause” Exception
Washington courts are hesitant to enforce a no-contest clause against a beneficiary who brings a challenge in good faith and with probable cause. This exception protects legitimate claims while allowing courts to distinguish them from lawsuits brought merely to pressure the estate or upset the testator’s plan. In this context, good faith concerns the beneficiary’s honesty and purpose in bringing the claim, while probable cause concerns whether the known facts supplied a reasonable basis for the claim. Washington courts often address these considerations together rather than applying separate formal tests.
Good faith and probable cause involve more than sincerely believing that something about the estate plan is wrong. Courts have applied the good faith and probable cause exception when the contestant took action on the advice of their lawyer. Although consulting a lawyer before filing is important, doing so does not automatically protect a beneficiary. The contesting beneficiary bears the initial burden of showing that the lawsuit was filed in good faith on the advice of fully informed counsel after a full and fair disclosure of all material facts, including facts that may weaken the proposed claim. If the beneficiary makes that showing, a rebuttable presumption of good faith arises. The opposing party may overcome the presumption with evidence of dishonesty, improper motive, lack of factual support, or the intentional withholding of material information. Estate of Gillespie (2020).
In Estate of Mumby (1999), a daughter challenged her father’s estate plan on the basis of undue influence. She told her attorney that her father was isolated, dependent on a neighbor, drank heavily, and experienced declining memory, vision, and hearing. She did not disclose that he had regular contact with people who lived with and visited him, remained in control of his finances and healthcare decisions, and had a longstanding relationship with the neighbor. Because she withheld material facts, the court found that she was not entitled to a presumption of good faith. The no-contest clause was enforced, and she lost her inheritance.
Not Every Estate Proceeding Is a Will Contest
A traditional will contest challenges the validity of a will based on testamentary incapacity, undue influence, fraud, improper execution, or another defect affecting the instrument’s validity. Washington law generally requires such a contest to be filed within four months after the will is admitted to probate, followed by personal service on the personal representative within 90 days after filing. RCW 11.24.010.
Other proceedings may affect the distribution of an estate without attacking the will’s validity. Depending on a no-contest clause’s language, these proceedings may fall inside or outside its scope. Examples include:
- presenting a later-dated will;
- petitioning to remove a personal representative;
- petitioning for an accounting;
- seeking to establish a lost will;
- asserting that a will was revoked by the testator or by operation of law;
- determining the effect of a beneficiary’s death before the testator;
- interpreting a will;
- resolving whether specifically devised property is no longer in the estate; or
- enforcing a contract to make a will.
Washington law distinguishes between challenging a will’s validity and asking a court to determine whether an otherwise valid will was later revoked or rendered wholly or partly inoperative. In Estate of Gherra (1954), the Washington Supreme Court explained that the latter type of proceeding does not constitute a “will contest” under Washington’s will-contest statute. But the statutory definition of a will contest does not necessarily determine whether a proceeding triggers a no-contest clause. That separate question depends on the language of the clause, which may reach conduct beyond a statutory will contest.
Claims based on rights independent of the will may also fall outside the scope of a no-contest clause. In Boettcher v. Busse (1954), a beneficiary brought an action based on an alleged oral contract under which the decedent had agreed to leave him a larger share. The court held that the claim did not trigger a clause prohibiting an attempt to “break” the will. Although the claim could reduce the property available for distribution under the will, it sought to enforce an independent contractual right rather than challenge the will’s validity.
Similarly, in Kellar v. Estate of Kellar (2012), the court concluded that a challenge to a prenuptial agreement did not trigger the will’s broad no-contest clause because the claim asserted rights independent of the will rather than challenging the will itself.
Proceed Carefully Before Filing
Disputes involving no-contest clauses require early and careful evaluation. If you think you have a claim challenging the validity of a loved one’s will that you are a beneficiary under, you will need to consider whether filing it could place an inheritance at risk. An experienced trust and estate litigation attorney can assess the clause, investigate the available evidence, and explain the potential consequences before litigation begins. Careful analysis before filing can help a beneficiary understand whether the proposed action may trigger the clause and whether the good faith and probable cause exception may apply.
Disclaimer. This article is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or a legal opinion. Every matter is different, and case outcomes depend on the specific facts and circumstances of each situation. Although Stokes Lawrence, P.S., strives to ensure the accuracy of the information presented, the law is continually evolving, and the information contained herein may not reflect the most recent legal developments or the current state of the law. You should consult competent legal counsel licensed in the appropriate jurisdiction regarding your particular circumstances. Reading, accessing, or relying on this article or website does not create an attorney-client relationship with Stokes Lawrence, P.S.